本港確診第二宗寨卡個案 男病人曾外遊蚊患區被叮

【宣誓覆核】黨報讚判決「維護法官正義形象」 區慶祥明言疑今次釋法違憲

2016-11-16 08:24
字體: A A A

香港高等法院法官區慶祥昨裁定,梁振英政府司法覆核青年新政梁頌恆及游蕙禎宣誓及立法會議員資格勝訴,大陸今日連《人民日報》全國版,都在第四版右下角有一段約700字的報道,標題為〈香港高等法院裁定取消兩名辱國候任議員的議員資格〉,內文還引述「香港社會各界」稱,今次裁決「真正維護了香港法治,維護了『一國兩制』,也維護了法官的正義形象。

不過,曾任特區政府高官多年的時事評論員王永平,在其《am730》今日專欄就提醒公眾,區慶祥在昨日判詞的第125段,其實指出人大今次釋法的意思和範圍,是否符合《基本法》第158條,可能存在爭議;只因與訟雙方都沒提出此點,所以不會評論。另外,區慶祥今次亦裁決,是法庭才有最終裁決權,裁定公職人員宣誓是否有效,而這也包括特首。

區慶祥相關判詞,原文如下:

125.  Given my acceptance of the CE and the SJ’s above submissions that the court would reach the same above conclusion for reasons I have explained above with or without referring to the terms of the Interpretation, this submission is irrelevant to the present proceedings and it is unnecessary for me to determine it.  I however think that it may be open to arguments that whether the Interpretation falls within the proper meaning and scope of “interpretation” as intended under BL158 is a final matter for the NPCSC, given that the NPCSC has the ultimate power to interpret the BL.  However, since this issue has not been argued substantively before me, I would refrain from saying anything further.

(圖片來源:人民日報截圖及蘋果日報)

請支持我們持續發展,透過PayPal或其他方法贊助我們!
金額:
分類:|發表於2016年11月16日 上午8:24

發表評論

讀取中…
有櫃員機鍵盤保護罩內 遭裝攝錄機偷拍輸入密碼